Made in the Lehigh Valley, PA

(484) 894-5416

Welcome to CJ's Mystic Mustard


About Us

Our Story

  • Carolyn has been creating gourmet mustard for over two decades. Started as a passion for cooking and gift giving Carolyn was dabbling with home made mustards, mixes, and other items to put in gift baskets for friends. Often, after receiving mustard, requests would come in for more mustard. With the popularity growing different flavors were added. Now there is a core of five mustards (Orignial, Lemon, Raspberry, Garlic, and Wasabi.) in addition to seasonal flavors.

Where to find our mustard

For Purchase:

Beef Jerky Outlet- Sands Outlets Bethlehem

Black River Farms, Bethlehem

Blue Mountain Winery- New Tripoli

Franklin Hill Vineyards- Breinigsville

Green Earth Marketplace- Emmaus

Pocono Oil & Spice Co.,  Tannersivlle

Saylor's & Co - Hellertown

Setter Ridge Vineyard, Kutztown

Trio County Butcher, East Texas

On the Menu at:

Colony Meadery- Bethlehem

TheMINT Gastropub- Bethlehem

Trio Country Butcher, East TX, PA


Melissa Wagner

"I am in love with her garlic mustard!!!! It is great with everything and super yummy."


"I am not usually the type to get excited about things like this, but I cannot get over how good this is. I'm hooked!"


"I used the mass-market version of this product for years, but the flavors that are available here made it an easy choice to buy here instead. I love the variety!"

Stay in Touch!

Contact Us

CJ's Gourmet Mystic Mustard

Hellertown, PA 18055, us

(484) 894-5416

Send Message

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.